Stitch Fix Review – Why I didn’t like it.

stitch-fix-review-02There’s a million glowing reviews for Stitch Fix… and I can see why.  It’s convenient, exciting, & much like ordering a present for yourself – but without knowing exactly what’s in the box.

However, all of my excitement came to a screeching halt when I opened my box to find absolutely nothing to my taste, size or fabric liking.  I was so sad.

In their detailed questionnaire, I gave them this to describe me:

“I am a homeschooling, mom w/ kids who lives in Maui. Getting dressed up here is like wearing a scarlet letter & out of place. I literally live in Yoga Pants or Running Shorts with a tank top, & flip flops. I am skinny (36/27/36), wear no jewelry, cook 5+ hours in the kitchen & garden outside. My style is Yoga chick meets Surfer chick (think Athleta). Can you help me? LOL!”

I also emphasized in the questions that: I am tiny, I am a mom, I don’t wear jewelry, I don’t need dressy, I like things casual, and I asked only for practical pieces that I could wear everyday.  I even gave them a Pinterest board with examples of what I wanted & liked – but I feel like it was totally ignored.

Here’s what I got:

4 Dressy Tank Tops & 1 Dressy Pleated Skirt – All in Hot, Sweaty, Polyester – and the shirts were HUGE on me.  All of the items were way too dressy for me – I don’t even get dressed up like this for church!  My stylist said ‘I could wear these tops, even with Yoga Pants!’… Um, I don’t thinks so.  But worst of all, was the one shirt that had cats with bows all over it – Ugh… it’s horrible! And, don’t they know, I’m a dog person. LOL!

Just to give you a size perspective, here’s one of my old shirts hanging over one they sent me:

Stitch Fix - Too Large

It was so big on me, you could see my boobs (or lack thereof) through the arm holes! Hahahaha!

Although some of the styles & colors are pretty, they were just too big to even try on – plus, I would never wear anything polyester in Hawaii.  The styles were also totally impractical for me – I prefer washable, cotton, fitted tanks or shirts.


I’d read all kinds of reviews about the prices, and so I prepared myself for everything to be very expensive.  I specifically requested the cheapest items possible.  Although it’s a lot more than I usually spend, the prices weren’t as bad as I expected.  If I had kept everything, all 5 pieces would have been $120… that’s only $24 per piece.

Stitch Fix Costs

I really wish they had gotten my style & needs right.  Needless to say, everything got packaged up and sent right back… and I won’t be trying the service again.

I think I’ll stick to my, Garage Sales & Black Friday Sales at Old Navy.

*** If you want to try ThredUp instead of Stitch Fix, here’s a link for $20 off your first order (good until 2/28 – after that, the coupon drops to$10 off)!  With that coupon, you can probably get something for free! =)  I just ordered 3 things from them and it only came to $8!  If you want to know more about ThredUp, click here or here (updated review) for my reviews. **


  1. Kelly K says

    Thank you so much for telling me about Thred Up! I’ve been using Stitch Fix with mixed results. I was so excited for find three tanks on Thred Up last night and getting them for $8 after coupon! Can’t wait to check out the site for kids’ clothes!

    • says

      Hi Kelly!

      You’re welcome! =) I’ve never been disappointed with ThredUp – I hope you will like them as much as we do!

      God Bless!

  2. Kate says

    The tone of my comment here is intended to be in “gentle kindness” – please don’t mis-interpret the written word).
    Did you miss the point of Stitch Fix? Their goal is to open our eyes to new styles and ideas..for us to have a little more fun and try new ideas. So many of us get stuck in a style rut and need some help trying new things! Their goal is not to give us what is already in our closet. I look for Stitch Fix to help me change up whats in my closet… give me fresh ideas to have a few new looks… kinda like a “makeover in a box”. All of the blouses they sent you were Adorable which is alot (coming from me … I am a cotton/comfy kind of gal !) I think they were just trying to open your eyes to new styles and looks. I’m sure you look great in your yoga clothing.. but, if you didn’t want to change-up your style what was it you were looking to get from the Stitch Fix gals? …. “just wondering”

    • says

      Aloha Kate!

      This is such a good question. If I didn’t convey it well enough, I was indeed looking for help in the style area and even ended my description to them with “Can you help me?”… because clearly I can use it! LOL! =)

      However, my disappointment was with a few key things I felt they clearly overlooked – especially when you’re paying for a ‘personal stylist’ to help. They sent me all Medium clothing – I weigh 100 pounds and am tiny; They sent me 100% Polyester clothing – not a good match for a hot & humid climate; and The style they picked for me, doesn’t fit my lifestyle or the location of where I live – I have no occasion to wear such dressy clothing. If you peeked at my Pinterest Style Board, I was hoping they could find a good balance between my frumpy Yoga Pants & a ‘chic’ active mom. LOL!

      If I lived on the mainland, or in an area where these styles were acceptable, the service might better suit me. Maybe my expectations were too high, or maybe they’ve just gotten busy enough that they can’t give the same personalized attention they once did… Either way, what I’ve learned is that this just isn’t for me.

      God Bless!
      ~ Erika

  3. says

    Erika, you are the consummate diplomat. I appreciate how clear and direct you were in your review.

    I can be a bit opinionated and like when I read something critical, backed up by fact and not emotion.

    I live on Kauai and found your site on youtube.

    You’ve gained my trust and I will be a regular visitor.

    A warm aloha,


    • says

      Aloha Pam!

      Thanks for the sweet comment. I wish all reviews could be great, but it doesn’t always turn out that way… So, I always try to be fair, honest & kind. I look forward to having you around. =)

      God Bless!
      ~ Erika

  4. Kate says

    Thanks Erika, It makes more sense to me now! It sounds like they missed it completely.

    Have a great day!

  5. Alison says

    I’m just surprised they sent you all mediums since size is something you pick in your style profile.

    Stitch Fix is awesome for a lot of people but it can’t be perfect for everyone.

    • says

      Hi Alison!

      I was surprised as well. One of my readers suggested that maybe they got my order mixed up with someone else’s. StitchFix keeps asking me to give them another shot… Maybe I will. I’ll keep you posted if I do. =)

      God Bless!
      ~ Erika

  6. Karen B. says

    I gave them 4 shots in a period of a year. The first time they got it almost right and I bought a shirt, wish I had kept two other pieces. the second time I kept nothing. Third time I kept one top and kind of wish I hadn’t. Fourth time, nothing. In my profile I wrote that I don’t wear any sleeveless tops and not to send me any. I got sleeveless tops and dresses (4 of them in one fix!) in every single fix. I asked for no pastels colors and got pastels in 3 of the 4. I am 51 and got a mini skirt and ripped jeans, both in this last same fix along with a sheer tank top (the other two items were a tulip sleeve blouse (essentially sleeveless) and a pastel knit top). Wha??

    So disappointed in wasting $20 and the excitement I felt when it came. :-(

  7. Lara says

    I’m in your same boat. I, too, am small (5’4″ 120 ‘lbs.) and only 1 item out of 2 shipments has even come close to fitting properly and almost none of the items were in line with my style or my VERY specific requests and wants. It’s like they don’t have the measurements of the blouses and dresses they are sending to match up with our bios. I’m giving them one last try with as much detail as I can so we’ll see! Oh, and I WISH I had received a couple of your pieces and for those prices! My totals were $200 and up and I also asked for the cheapest price point possible. Stitch Fix is fixin’ to get the boot.

    • says

      Thanks Lara, I’m glad I’m not the only one! I have tried them 3 times now and have been disappointed each time! They keep sending me everything in polyester even though I requested NO POLYESTER in all caps in both my profile and note to stylist. And you’re right, the prices have increased substantially… which is so sad, because I really wanted to love Stitch Fix! Hope you’re latest attempt was more successful than mine. =) God Bless! ~Erika

  8. alyssa says

    I just got my first fix last week, and I bought three of the five items. I’m pretty happy about it all but I am concerned about a few loose threads on all the items. Overall I am glad I ordered, everything fit but the pants. I am a 24/00 and they only have 25/0. I have a bazillion pinterest boards and she looked at them all and did a good job finding things I would like. I was VERY nervous

    • says

      Hi Alyssa! It sounds like you’ve had a really good experience with Stitch Fix… that’s awesome! I’ll bet having all those Pins really helped your stylist a lot. One of these days I hope to try again and have better luck. God Bless! ~Erika

  9. Alexa says

    Based on what I just read, it sounds like you have no sense of style, nor do you have any interest in developing one.

    I understand the miss on the fit and the polyester problem. Stitch Fix sometimes needs more than one chance to get it right. It’s like building a relationship; it takes some time.

    When you choose the “cheap as possible” option, you often get a lot of polyester, because it’s cheap.

    That being said, I found all of the styles they sent you to be on trend, with a nice variety.

    Why not start a trend in your community by raising the bar on your personal fashion sense? Believe it or not, it could make a major, positive impact on your life.

    Maybe you’re tired of dressing like a common person and you want more out of life.

    Why not try Stitch Fix again? Just update your profile to indicate you want natural fibers, tell them you’re an extra small in size and increase the amount you’re willing to pay.

    You contacted Stitch Fix for a reason. Why not give it another go?

    All of those glowing reviews are out there for a reason.

    • says

      Hi Alexa!

      You’re right, a ‘sense of style’ is definitely not my forte… which is exactly why I tried Stitch Fix to begin with. With my first fix, I clearly specified ‘no synthetic fabrics’ because I live in Hawaii. I don’t have A/C, so it isn’t uncommon for my house to be 105 degrees & humid. Wearing cool cottons is really one of my only options.

      Also, if you’ve spent anytime on a small island (in the poorest communities), a tank top, shorts & slippers (aka $1 flipflops) is ‘dressed-up’. My ministry here has always been to be active in my community by reaching out to my neighbors and caring for children (not the rich tourists) – So setting a new ‘trend’ here would mean associating myself as an affluent outsider.

      Lastly, since writing this post, I am on my 4th Stitch Fix… so I have given them multiple tries. So far, they’ve completely ignored my very specific requests – even sending me a pair of felt skinny jeans & long sleeved shirts. I don’t think selecting the ‘as cheap as possible’ option has made any difference in the styles they are choosing for me.

      What I’m starting to figure out, is that Stitch Fix really isn’t interested in helping me find clothes that fit my lifestyle – but rather have me conform to the style of whatever they have purchased in bulk. Which is unfortunate, because I would have loved for it to work out.

      God Bless!

  10. Lisa Schaaf says

    I loved stitch fix when they first started. Then this year, I too felt NO ONE was reading my comments. One, I say I’m allergic to wool in my profile…so they send a wool sweater. Then I say no dresses, 2 months in a row they send a black and white stripe dress. I cancel automatic shipment…3 weeks later get notice my order shipped. I think I did something wrong, go in again and cancel (I was on every other month shipment when I did have have auto ship scheduled). 3 weeks later, today, another notice of shipment. This time I took a screen shot of my cancellation to send to my credit card company when I dispute the shipping charge. I can’t cancel my account as I have to wait for the shipment to arrive, and send it back. I used to be such a big fan.

  11. Laura says

    Complete waste of time! Filled out all the info and they sent me nothing that fit my profile. Second fix was just as bad. When I said I was leaving they convinced me to stay and give them one more chance and asked me to write out a detailed description of my preferences. I did. The next fix was even worse! I’m convinced they just have a warehouse of styles they are trying to pawn off on people. They prices aren’t even that great and they clearly don’t try to personalize it AT ALL!! I’m done!

  12. April says

    I love clothes, love to shop and like to shop for people. I was super excited to try stitch fix, My final total was $300.00. I said no petite and they sent 3 petite dresses! This was their response: It looks like you aren’t interested in receiving pieces unless they are under $35. I want to be very upfront in letting you know that our items typically start around $48, with the bulk of our inventory priced between $60 and $80. We really want to remain sensitive to your preferred price point, but there may be some variation of the cost of items since we want to give you the best selection possible given your style and fit preferences. Our stylists will do their best to stick to our lowest price points, but can’t guarantee every piece will fall into that category.
    They could have said that in the beginning, I like your total better! 😬 They give an option as cheap as I can I can get it! i don’t think they meant to have that there!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *